Blog:

The MV Dali and the Francis Scott Key Bridge Collapse: A Maritime Tragedy with Lasting Lessons

Introduction

On March 26, 2024, the maritime world witnessed a catastrophic event when the Singapore-flagged container ship MV Dali collided with the Francis Scott Key Bridge in Baltimore, Maryland, causing its collapse. This incident, resulting in the tragic loss of six construction workers, significant economic disruption, and environmental concerns, underscored the critical importance of vessel reliability, emergency preparedness, and regulatory oversight. As a chief engineer or maritime professional, understanding the causes, response, and lessons from this incident is essential for enhancing safety and preventing future tragedies. This blog delves into the MV Dali collision, analyzing its timeline, causes, consequences, and implications for the maritime industry, with practical insights for engineers and operators.

Timeline of the MV Dali Incident

The MV Dali, a Neopanamax container ship with a capacity of 9,971 TEU, was built in 2015 by Hyundai Heavy Industries and operated by Synergy Marine Group under the ownership of Grace Ocean Pte Ltd. On March 26, 2024, the 984-foot vessel, carrying nearly 4,700 containers, was departing the Port of Baltimore for Colombo, Sri Lanka, when disaster struck. Below is a detailed timeline based on reports from sources like the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), news outlets, and maritime trackers:

March 25, 2024 (Monday): The MV Dali completed routine engine maintenance at the Seagirt Marine Terminal in Baltimore, having arrived from the Port of Norfolk. No issues were reported during a U.S. Coast Guard inspection. The vessel, crewed by 22 Indian seafarers and two Maryland pilots, prepared for its 27-day voyage.

March 26, 2024, 12:30 AM EDT: The Dali departed the Seagirt Marine Terminal, moving at approximately 8 knots (9 mph) toward the Francis Scott Key Bridge, a 1.6-mile truss bridge spanning the Patapsco River.

1:24 AM: The ship experienced a momentary loss of propulsion and electrical power, as evidenced by its lights shutting off, captured in video footage. The crew issued a mayday call, alerting the Maryland Transportation Authority (MDTA) to the loss of control.

1:25 AM: The ship’s lights briefly flickered back on, indicating a partial restoration of power, possibly from emergency generators. Black smoke billowed from the chimney, suggesting attempts to restart the engines or reverse thrust.

1:27 AM: The MDTA duty officer radioed units to close the bridge to traffic, a critical action that likely saved lives by halting vehicles. However, a construction crew filling potholes on the bridge could not be evacuated in time.

1:29 AM: The Dali struck a support pillar of the Francis Scott Key Bridge at approximately 1:29:33 AM, causing the central truss arch to collapse within seconds. A section of the bridge fell onto the ship’s bow, grounding it in the Patapsco River. Six of the eight construction workers on the bridge were killed, with two rescued from the water.

Immediate Aftermath: Rescue operations began swiftly, with the U.S. Coast Guard and local authorities searching for survivors. The Port of Baltimore, a major hub handling 30,000 daily commuters and significant cargo, was closed, trapping 40 vessels inside.

May 13–20, 2024: After weeks of salvage efforts, controlled explosives removed bridge debris pinning the Dali. On May 20, tugboats towed the vessel 2.5 miles to the Seagirt Marine Terminal for inspection and debris removal. The temporary federal channel was widened to 400 feet, allowing partial port reopening.

June–November 2024: The Dali sailed to Virginia International Gateway in Hampton Roads on June 25 to unload cargo, then proceeded to China’s Fujian Huadong Shipyard for repairs to its bow, deck, machinery, anchors, thrusters, and electrical systems. The vessel began sea trials on January 12, 2025.

Ongoing (March 2025): Eleven of the 21 crew members remain in Baltimore for NTSB and FBI investigations, supported by organizations like the Baltimore International Seafarers’ Center. The port’s permanent 700-foot channel is expected to reopen by late 2025, with bridge reconstruction estimated at $1.9 billion and four years.

Causes of the Collision

The NTSB and U.S. Coast Guard are still investigating the precise cause of the MV Dali’s power loss, but preliminary findings and expert analyses point to several factors:

Power Failure: The ship experienced a “momentary loss of propulsion” and electrical blackout, likely due to a failure in its diesel generators or fuel system. Video evidence shows the lights shutting off and on, suggesting issues with the ship’s four independent diesel generators or their electrical systems. The steering system, reliant on electric pumps for hydraulic rudder control, was also disabled during the blackout.

Previous Incidents: The Dali had a history of issues. In July 2016, it collided with a stone pier in Antwerp, Belgium, damaging its stern and the berth. In June 2023, a port state control inspection in San Antonio, Chile, identified a faulty fuel pressure gauge, which was repaired before departure. These incidents raise questions about the vessel’s maintenance history.

Maneuvering Challenges: At 8 knots in the narrow Patapsco River channel, the Dali’s size (984 feet, 116,851 DWT) left little margin for error. Without propulsion or steering, the ship’s momentum and possible starboard rudder position during the blackout caused it to veer into the bridge’s support pillar.

Human Factors: While the crew issued a timely mayday call, the 90 seconds between the blackout and collision were insufficient to regain control or evacuate the bridge’s construction crew. The presence of two Maryland pilots, trained to navigate local waters, could not prevent the incident due to the rapid loss of control.

Bridge Design: Built in 1972, the Francis Scott Key Bridge lacked modern protective structures like fender systems or dolphins, which could have mitigated the impact. The NTSB is reviewing the bridge’s design as part of its investigation.

The city of Baltimore alleges in court filings that Grace Ocean and Synergy Marine knowingly allowed an “unseaworthy” vessel to depart, citing a power supply issue hours before sailing. The companies dispute this, claiming no prior knowledge of faults and seeking to limit liability to $43.6 million under the U.S. Limitation of Liability Act of 1851.

Response and Salvage Efforts

The response to the MV Dali incident was swift and multifaceted, involving rescue, salvage, and environmental protection:

Rescue Operations: The crew’s mayday call enabled the MDTA to close the bridge to traffic, preventing additional casualties. Rescue teams recovered two workers from the water, but six others perished. Divers searched through twisted metal in 47°F water, recovering bodies over weeks.

Salvage Operations: A Unified Command, comprising the U.S. Coast Guard, Army Corps of Engineers, and Maryland authorities, coordinated debris removal. On May 13, controlled explosives detached bridge wreckage from the Dali. By May 20, tugboats moved the ship to the Seagirt Marine Terminal, a process taking 21 hours due to the vessel’s 106,000-ton weight and debris.

Port Reopening: The temporary 400-foot-wide, 50-foot-deep channel allowed partial resumption of commercial traffic by late May 2024. The permanent 700-foot channel is targeted for completion by late 2025, restoring full port operations.

Crew Support: The 21 Indian and one Sri Lankan crew members faced significant challenges, with 11 remaining in Baltimore as of March 2025 for investigations. The Baltimore International Seafarers’ Center provided mental health support, religious services, and outings to alleviate the crew’s isolation, as their phones were confiscated by the FBI.

Environmental Measures: The Dali carried 764 tons of hazardous materials in 56 containers, including explosives, corrosives, and lithium-ion batteries, with some breached. Authorities monitored for fuel leaks from the ship’s 1.5 million gallons of diesel, reporting no significant pollution.

Environmental and Economic Impacts

The collapse had profound environmental and economic consequences:

Environmental Risks: Breached containers containing hazardous materials posed risks of water contamination in the Patapsco River. The ship’s fuel tanks, while intact, required careful monitoring to prevent leaks. The Unified Command’s environmental teams used infrared cameras and containment measures to mitigate risks.

Economic Disruption: The Port of Baltimore, the 20th largest in the U.S. by tonnage, was paralyzed, affecting 30,000 daily commuters and supply chains for automobiles, coal, and consumer goods. Losses are estimated at $2–4 billion, including bridge reconstruction ($1.9 billion), salvage ($19.5 million), and ship repairs ($28 million). General Average was declared, requiring cargo owners to share salvage costs.

Human Toll: The loss of six construction workers, primarily immigrants, highlighted the vulnerability of infrastructure workers. The incident also impacted the crew’s mental health, with ongoing support needed for those stranded in Baltimore.

Lessons for the Maritime Industry

The MV Dali incident offers critical lessons for chief engineers, ship operators, and regulators, particularly in light of your interest in maritime safety and ISM compliance:

Power System Reliability: The blackout underscores the need for robust maintenance of auxiliary generators and electrical systems. Chief engineers should:

Conduct regular load tests on diesel generators, ensuring redundancy per SOLAS requirements.

Inspect fuel systems, including pressure gauges and pumps, to prevent failures like the one detected in Chile in 2023.

Maintain emergency generators for instant activation during blackouts, as delays of 30–60 seconds can be catastrophic.

Emergency Preparedness: The mayday call and bridge closure demonstrate the value of rapid communication. Engineers should:

Conduct frequent blackout drills, simulating loss of propulsion and steering in confined waters (ISM Element 8).

Ensure crew familiarity with emergency steering systems and backup power activation.

Vessel Maintenance: The Dali’s prior incidents suggest maintenance gaps. Chief engineers must:

Adhere to the Planned Maintenance System (PMS) for critical systems, logging all tasks per ISM Element 10.

Use predictive tools like vibration analysis and thermal imaging to detect issues in generators and propulsion systems.

Navigation in Confined Waters: The narrow Patapsco River channel amplified the incident’s severity. Operators should:

Use tugboat escorts for large vessels in high-risk areas, despite cost pressures. X posts suggest tugs could not have stopped the Dali at 8 knots, but their presence might have mitigated drift.

Ensure pilots are supported by real-time vessel status updates from the engine room.

Regulatory Oversight: The incident highlights gaps in aging infrastructure and vessel inspections. Regulators should:

Strengthen port state control inspections for propulsion and electrical systems, as per Tokyo MOU guidelines.

Mandate protective structures (e.g., fenders) for bridges near shipping lanes.

Crew Welfare: The prolonged detention of the Dali crew underscores the need for mental health support under MLC 2006. Companies must provide counseling and communication access during investigations.

← Back to Blog